Rijal Al Kashi Report 176 -2021- [patched] May 2026

Rijal al-Kashshi Report 176 details a pivotal moment following the peace treaty between Imam Hasan and Muawiya, where Imam Hasan and Imam Husayn were summoned to pledge allegiance. The report highlights a crucial exchange where Imam Husayn, directing Qays ibn Sa’d, reinforces that his obedience was exclusively to Imam Hasan. This narrative is frequently cited in modern discourse to explain the Shi'ite perspective on the strategic nature of Imam Hasan’s actions to preserve the community. For an in-depth discussion on this report, see the community analysis on

Narrative Evaluation: Reviewing whether a narrator was a "Ghali" (extremist) or "Thiqah" (trustworthy) according to al-Kashshi's specific criteria.

Report 176 centers on the evaluation of a specific narrator, often involving a direct endorsement or rejection by an Imam. In the context of Rijal al-Kashi, such reports typically follow a structure where a companion asks the Imam regarding the trustworthiness of an individual who narrates traditions. The significance of Report 176 lies in its nuanced approach to verification. Unlike simple binary classifications of "truthful" or "liar," many reports in this section of al-Kashi’s work deal with the gray areas of narration—individuals who may be pious but have poor memory, or those who are reliable in theology but unreliable in the exact wording of transmission. Rijal Al Kashi Report 176 -2021-

Relevance to contemporary hadith authentication – In 2021, a number of online Shi’i forums began citing Report 176 to argue that an otherwise reliable narrator could become unreliable later in life. The academic reports clarified that al-Kashi’s method requires strict chronological biography — something missing from most classical entries.

It seems you’re referring to a document titled “Rijal Al Kashi Report 176 -2021-” — possibly a file, analysis, or study related to the Rijal (biographical evaluation) tradition in Islamic scholarship, with reference to Al-Kashi (most likely Abu ‘Amr Muhammad ibn ‘Umar al-Kashshi, author of Ma‘rifat akhbar al-rijal, one of the earliest Shi’i rijal books). Rijal al-Kashshi Report 176 details a pivotal moment

Further Reading (Scholarly):

Critique of Worldly Power: It highlights the Imams' consistent warning against entanglement with oppressive political structures, even at the tribal level. This is an internal or unpublished document

1. This is an internal or unpublished document.
2. The title is a reference to a specific report from a private organization, research group, or online forum.
3. There is a mix-up in naming — perhaps a misremembered title or citation.

In the academic study of Shia Hadith, Rijal al-Kashi is one of the four primary books on the biographies of narrators (Rijal). The report numbers in the 2021 English translation series (specifically the translation by al-Qazwini) correspond to specific narrations regarding the reliability of traditionists.